APPEALS COURT'S DECISION IS HIGHLY FLAWED

By Harut SassounianPublisher, The California Courier The federal Court of Appeals issued a shocking decision last week. In a unanimous ruling, it struck down a California law that had allowed heirs of Armenian Genocide victims to sue life insurance companies for unpaid claims. Acknowledging its reliance on the "rarely invoked doctrine" of "field preemption," the Court judged the state law to be unconstitutional, claiming that it intruded into the federal government's foreign policy prerogative. The Appeals Court thus annulled a law passed by the California legislature in 2000, which had extended first to 2010 and then to 2016, the deadline for Armenian Genocide heirs to sue life insurance companies. On the basis of that law, California attorneys filed lawsuits against the New York Life and French AXA insurance companies. Both lawsuits were settled out of court for a total payment of $37.5 million. In 2003, Armenian plaintiffs filed a class-action lawsuit in U.S. federal court against German life insurance companies. Rather than fulfilling their long overdue contractual obligations, these companies sought the lawsuit's dismissal, arguing that the reference to the Armenian Genocide in the State law was an encroachment on the federal government's foreign policy powers. After several appeals, a panel of 11 federal judges dismissed the lawsuit against the German companies on February 23, 2012. This decision, however, does not undo the settlements reached earlier with New York Life and AXA. I believe the for the following reasons: 1) The Court took the unusual position that the State law constituted an intrusion into the federal government's foreign policy domain, even in the absence of any conflict between the two. In fact, the State of California and the federal government are in agreement on the genocide issue, since the House of Representatives recognized the Armenian Genocide in 1975 and 1984, Pres. Reagan acknowledged it in a Presidential Proclamation in 1981, and most importantly, the U.S. Justice Department cited the Armenian case as an example of genocide in an official report submitted to the World Court in 1951. 2) The Appeals Court overstepped its judicial bounds by paying undue attention to Turkish denials, pressures, and blackmail, and charging that the California statute "imposes the politically charged label of 'genocide' on the actions of the Ottoman Empire (and, consequently, present-day Turkey) and expresses sympathy for 'Armenian Genocide victims.'" This assertion is totally untrue, as the California law makes no reference to "present-day Turkey." Delving further into political arguments rather than sound legal judgments, the Appeals Court quoted from newspaper articles -- that were not part of the court record -- to illustrate Turkey's angry reaction to the French bill on penalizing genocide denial and Ankara's rejection of the genocide label. 3) The Court could have severed the reference to genocide from the California statute, while keeping valid the legitimate demands of life insurance claimants, since the purpose of the lawsuit was the recovery of insurance benefits, not asserting genocide. Armenians should not be discouraged and not give up the struggle for their legitimate rights, despite this temporary legal setback. Here are some possible steps that could be taken to remedy the situation: 1) File an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, even though the High Court hears only a very small percentage of the cases submitted to it. 2) Ask the California legislature to pass a new law that would broaden the category of possible claimants, in order to overcome the Appeals Court's objection that the existing law is "for a narrowly defined class of claims." 3) Lobby the U.S. Congress to pass similar legislation allowing lawsuits against delinquent insurance companies. 4) Launch a new Armenian political initiative at the federal level, seeking the establishment of a "Presidential Advisory Commission on Armenian Genocide Assets," similar to the existing commission on the Holocaust, which would use U.S. governmental channels rather than the courts to recover genocide-era assets. 5) Embark on a worldwide campaign to protest and boycott German insurance companies that refuse to live up to their financial and moral obligations. Stage demonstrations in front of German companies' offices in different countries until they realize that they would lose more business by ignoring the Armenian claims than paying the amounts owed to heirs of life insurance beneficiaries. Furthermore, Armenians must demand that Germany, Turkey's ally during World War I, passes a law mandating that German companies pay delinquent insurance claims. Clearly, the pursuit of Armenian demands is more of a marathon than a sprint! Armenians must persist in their struggle and overcome all obstacles until their long overdue quest for justice is realized.

| Home | >>

Translate

RSS © A1+

Headlines for March 12, 2012

APPEALS COURT'S DECISION IS HIGHLY FLAWED
By Harut SassounianPublisher, The California Courier The federal Court of Appeals issued a shocking decision last week. In a unanimous ruling, it struck down a California law that had allowed heirs of ...
HHK IS POWERFUL, THOUGH DIFFIDENT
The Republican Party of Armenia (HHK) is so powerful that any system, any economic structure even the one that has oligarchs in its infrastructures, can rely on it, said Republican MP Vardan Ayvazyan. He ...
U.S. AND ITS ALLIES CONSIDER MILITARY STEPS IN SYRIA
The Obama administration and its allies and international partners have begun serious discussions about potential military involvement in Syria, even as they continue to press for nonviolent solutions ...
POLICE LOOKING FOR PERSON WHO FILMED HRAZDAN ELECTION BRIBERY
The Police Kotayk Regional Department has launched an investigation based upon a news report that appeared in Hetq's February 12 edition. The case is filed against Ashot Danileyan who is charged with ...
WILL PUTIN TWIST SARGSYAN'S ARMS
The March 6 parliamentary elections will be the most important in the history of Armenia since the country will be holding the first election after the March 2008 bloodshed, says Director of Regional ...
SARKOZY APOLOGISES FOR HIS SON'S TOMATO PRANK
French President Nicolas Sarkozy publically apologised to a policewoman after his teenage son and his friends threw a tomato and pellets at her from the presidential palace. Louis Sarkozy, 15, and two ...
HERITAGE REP, POLISH AMBASSADOR DISCUSS POLITICAL SITUATION IN ARMENIA
Head of the Heritage parliamentary faction Styopa Safaryan today met at the Armenian National Assembly Polish Ambassador to Armenia Zdislaw Rachinsky. At the request of the Polish ambassador, Mr Safaryan ...
KOKOBELYAN: "OUTCOME OF ELECTIONS DEPENDS ON PROXIES"
The Republican Party of Armenia (HHK) should be interested in holding free and fair elections, the leader of the Free Democrats party Khachatur Kokobelyan said on Monday."But it does not mean that they ...
BUSINESS AND POLITICS: ARE THEY CORRELATED?
Why does Armenia-based businessman, owner of Shirak football club Arman Sahakyan want to enter parliament? Arman Sahakyan, one of the 10 largest taxpayers in Armenia, is the founder of Sovrano Company ...
SAMVEL BALASANYAN SUBMITS DOCUMENTS
Vice-Speaker of the Armenian National Assembly Samvel Balasanyan, who is going to run for the majoritarian seat in a single-mandate constituency, today submitted the necessary documents to the territorial ...
YEREVAN TO HOST OPEN-AIR PHOTO EXHIBITION
An open-air photo exhibition will be held at Yerevan's Republican Square at 12:00, March 12. The exhibition organised by the "Dignified transport" civil initiative will focus on the current state of public ...
POST-SCRIPTUM TO HOST EDUARD SHARMAZANOV
The program Post-Scriptum will host on Monday Eduard Sharmazanov, Vice-Speaker of the Armenian National Assembly and Spokesman for the ruling Republican Party of Armenia (HHK). You can send your questions ...
DOCTORS DISAPPROVE OF CONSTRUCTION AT MASHTOTS PARK
A group of employees of Polyclinic No. 2 and Yerevan State Medical University expressed their disapproval of a controversial construction at the capital's Mashtots Park. "As usual, they subordinate public ...
BABIES BORN WITH DEFECTS
Statistics reveals that 30-35% of babies are born with birth defects. However, specialists cannot find reasons for this phenomenon. Birth rate has not shown any increase in Shrak marz, which, according ...
INVITATION TO WORK WITH A1+
A1+ Company is inviting journalists with work experience. For more details you can contact the company calling at 585 427 or writing at a1plus@a1plus.am.
WASHINGTON POST: GAS PRICES SINK OBAMA'S RATINGS
Disapproval of President Obama's handling of the economy is heading higher - alongside gasoline prices - as a record number of Americans now give the president "strongly" negative reviews on the 2012 ...
RUMORS ABOUT KAREN AVAGYAN ARE EXAGGERATED
Republican MP Karen Avagyan dismisses press reports that he wants to become rector of Yerevan State Medical University. "This is nonsense," Avagyan told A1+. In reply to our next question whether he was ...
HANRAPETUTYUN PARTY TO NOMINATE CANDIDATES BY MAJORITARIAN SYSTEM
The Hanrapetutyun (Republic) Party will nominate more than ten candidates by the majoritarian system, according to the party leader Aram Sargsyan. The party has not changed its decision regarding its ...
ICRC GIVEN LIST OF 90 ARMENIAN CAPTIVES
The number of Armenians held captive in Azerbaijan has considerably increased since the outbreak of the Nagorno-Karabakh war. The State Commission on Prisoners of War, Hostages and Missing Persons has ...
FORMER HHSH REP VS HHSH CHAIRMAN
Former political prisoner Suren Sirunyan, who was arrested in connection with the March 2008 post-election clashes, will run in the May 6 parliamentary elections. "I shall be nominated at electoral district ...
ARMENIAN FM INVITED TO SWITZERLAND
At the invitation of his Swiss counterpart Didier Burkhalter, Armenia's Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian will visit Switzerland on March 13-14, RA MFA Press Service reports.
ARMENIAN FM, CSTO SECRETARY MEET IN YEREVAN
Armenian Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian received on Monday Secretary General of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), Nikolay Bordyuzha. The interlocutors discussed implementation of ...